Debunking Florida’s needs for vouchers

The crux of John East’s argument for vouchers is different
children learn in different ways. He however never takes the time to explain
how private schools that take vouchers teach any differently than their public
school counterparts. He seems to just take it on faith that we will understand
what he means. Do private schools have some miraculous instruction delivery
system that public schools should emulate? He seems to imply that when he talks
about how well they students who take vouchers are doing. The truth is whether
it is a private school, charter school or a public school; they all have the
same basic set up, a teacher giving instruction to their students.
Public schools however have to have certified teachers,
recognized curriculums and are required to engage in accountability measures.
The private schools that take vouchers don’t but somehow Mr. East expects us to
believe they are doing just as well and people are clamoring to get into them.
Recent revelations that Step up for Students undoubtedly
uses public money to lobby for even more public money and they don’t actually
keep a wait list of families that have applied for a voucher, other than on the
back of an envelope, John East’s own words on a post on his blog ReDefined ED,
one of their assertions about why they should be allowed to expand, should make
one skeptical about everything about the organization. In his own letter to you
he mentions that the increase to vouchers would only be 90 million over the
next three years but fails to mention that the aggregate loss to public schools
would be about 1.6 billion and in 2016, Step up for Students administrative
fees would jump from 8 to about 24 million dollars. Also where does it stop?
How much siphoned away from public schools is enough?
Of the 1,425 schools that take vouchers, over 160 teach
creationism as science and none have to have certified teachers or a recognized
curriculum. He also takes liberties with his assertions. Research shows that
“some” were struggling academically in the schools they left behind, some
however were doing very well and some left great schools to take vouchers most
likely for religious preferences.  As
for taking a standardized test they don’t take the same tests public school
students do, something East has lobbied against them doing, so how can we make
an apple to apples comparison?
I spoke with David Figilo the states experts on vouchers and
he said as a group students in private schools that take vouchers don’t perform
any better than their public school counterparts. He went on to tell me there
were some really excellent private schools that take vouchers, mostly religious
schools, but there were some very poor ones too. I would like to add private
schools that take vouchers can pick who they take and keep and can put requirements
on parents something public schools can’t do.
Then there are lots of reasons why people might oppose the
expansion of vouchers too. First for religious reasons, it doesn’t just blur
the line between church and state it obliterates it. Then there is
accountability, that John East and many voucher supporters’ fight against. They
may take a test but there is no direct comparison between how voucher kids and
public school kids are doing. Then it annually siphons hundreds of millions out
of public schools, which are already starved for resources, and out of the tax
base that goes to pay for other state services.
Vouchers undoubtedly do help a few students but if we are
being honest how many students couldn’t get the same services in their public
schools. Should the public really be forced to fund someone’s religious choice,
distrust of “gov’ment” schools or irrational hatred of teacher unions?  Should we really be handicapping the many to
help a few?
Given the recent revelations about Step up for Students, the
facts that they resist accountability and don’t provide better education
outcomes, instead of being allowed to expand, the program should be put under a
microscope to see if something of this scale is truly needed.

To read John easts’s self serving piece in the Gainesville Sun, click the

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *